Tuesday, February 2, 2016

How Space is Embedded in the Practice of Everyday Life?



HOW SPACE IS EMBEDDED IN THE PRACTICE OF EVERYDAY LIFE?

Space and Language
The language of space is not abstract at all, but it is essentially human one.
Bryan Lawson, The Language of Space

We as human constantly belong in space, either consciously and unconsciously, both in natural environment as well in man-made one. Space omnipresence is inseparable within our concept of reality, but at the same time we do not only passively exist in space but rather we actively act in it, we dwell. As quoted from George Herbert Mead, on his later published writing, “The environment must lie in some sense inside the act if the form is to respond to him.”[1]
Though almost never explicitly enunciated, space and human are communicating continuously throughout time. The language of space is essentially non-verbal. We do not express such things in words because they are based on implicit knowledge.[2] This implicit manner does not imply that the language of space is communicating intangibly, it has the capability to situate, posit, force its inhabitant tangibly and unnoticed.
As we dwell and communicate with and within space, form is acting as the most appealing quality perceivable through our senses. Even in the case of having an almost permanent and static physical qualities, one form could trigger vastly different qualities towards people. According to Hertzberger, form has an accommodating capacity or ‘competence’, which allows it to be filled with associations and thus brings about a mutual dependence with the users. He further explained form can be vested with meaning, but can also be divested of it by the use to which the form is put and by the values that are attributed and added to it, or indeed removed from it – all depending on the way in which users and form interact.[3] Clearly described that the decisive matter between man and space is not about the importance or dominance of any parties, rather what is crucial is the interaction between the two.

Human and Place
To be in a place is a requisite condition for human to exist but simultaneously it also means human bodily takes or occupies the locus, which is generally defined as location (or stance). Unlike location, position is defined towards its relation to the otherness in its situation, this relational concept is characterizing the place both physically and socially.[4] A place therefore is created by and within its surroundings including every stakes or parties localized in its relation. Thus every place is considerably a situation which has its structure and its own logic on constructing its particularity. This particularity is tangibly inscribed in its physical qualities, it further determines physical space into social space.
In another scale, the place occupier as well, may be characterized by his or her place where he or she is situated more or less permanently. In every moment within a society, one has to deal with a set of activities or of things which are determined and characterized relationally in spatial and social context. Human in that context as a social agent is pre-molded by his/her location (place taking), position (relational concept), and disposition (habitus), on acting or behaving in the most diverse domains of practice.[5] Clearly, there is a direct determination between physical and social space, as Bourdieu puts it, spatial distances on paper are equivalent to social distances.
Being in a particular place, human fundamentally never lives in a social vacuum, indisputably human always is situated in a structured social context which Bourdieu calls “fields.” He further explains that fields are competitive arenas of struggle over different kinds of capital, fields offer constraints and opportunities independent of the resources brought by the actor in his/her situation.[6]

Building and Dwelling
As Hans van der Laan beautifully depicted our mutual communication with space, as follows, “The ground being too hard for our bare feet we make ourselves sandals of softer material than the ground, but tougher than our feet. Were they as hard as the ground or as soft as our feet they would give us no advantage, but being just hard enough to stand up to wear and yet just soft enough to be comfortable, they bring about a harmony between our tender feet and the rough ground.”[7] Sandals are assigned here for describing the role of architecture, especially in its relation with nature. Hans van der Laan made a stance that architecture is not an entity derives within itself, but rather an entity required to exist for communication, as a platform of interaction between human and natural space.
With its role between man and natural space, architecture has started long before its bodily appearance, and end sometimes long after they have gone, as slowly fading images in their former dwellers’ minds.[8] A building is constructed, planned, designed, discussed, desired, needed much earlier than the appearance of its physical presence, only by then its existence has a position in its context both physically and mentally. A building existence is therefore much more complex than only to serve its labelled function, because its emergence as a ‘need’ (before it was built), was located in its dwellers’ life. Accordingly a house is not similar than a home, its physicality and its notion is weaved and embedded to its dweller’s life and within the context which it exists.
For the notion of home is deeply weaved in a person or in community and the need of its existence has existed much before its physical appearance, therefore the process of its emergence is as well grow within the context. “Building and settlements are the visible expression of the relative importance attached to different aspects of life and the varying ways of perceiving reality.”[9] The notion of home, is in itself, surpasses beyond its physical entity, it is not mere a physical building, it is a social structure, and moreover it is perspective of dwelling.

Habitus
To be in a particular position in a structure and to dwell along with certain logic of practice in a long period of time in a place, human will develop an incorporated structure or a practice notion known as ‘habitus’. Pierre Bourdieu, a French sociologist introduces the notion of ‘habitus’ as he explained it in his lecture in University of Oslo, ‘habitus’ are structures incorporated into appropriated physical space as generative and unifying principles which works as cognitive schemas, systems, principle of vision and division in a particular place. Applicably it generates and organizes practices and representations than can be objectively adapted to their outcomes without presupposing a conscious aiming at ends or an express mastery of the operations necessary in order to attain them.
Further explained ,in practice this notion will generate sort of the “reasonable”, “common-sense”, behaviors which are possible within the limits of these regularities, and which are likely to be positively sanctioned because they are objectively adjusted to the logic characteristic of a particular field, whose objective future they anticipate.[10]
As part of the party who influences habitus, spatial quality stands as one of the most influential yet invisible. So as the implicit manner of language of space, as it performs on a social agent it molds, shapes and situates him/her in daily practice. Spatial impact will imply the pace of a day, the logic of the environment, the pressure and recess of agent’s situation, and moreover, the context or background of any daily practice, which further on will determine the value of the daily practice itself.
The structure of place is constructed by its physicality which also possess and signifies its greater existence as a being. This duality of space are impactful to its user only by means of experience within the context along the everyday life. Descriptively human acts within the structure, by then he/she will get to understand of how the things would work in itself and within its situation, afterward the logic of the structure will tangibly be experienced and practiced by him/her (with/without consciousness practiced). As the logic is repeatedly practiced, it will be inscribed as a bodily pattern or traces on the actor’s practice.

Property appropriates its owner, embodying itself in the form of a structure generating practices perfectly conforming with its logic and its demands.
Pierre Bourdieu. Structures, Habitus, Practices (p. 282)

Matter and Consciousness
Before proceeding further towards implication of habitus, argument about the nature of human mind towards the environment must beforehand be established, to be able to describe the whole process of space (built environment) in human’s consciousness. According to George H. Mead, as he observed kids, an object arises in consciousness through the merging of the imagery from past experiences of the response with that of the sensuous experience of the current stimulation, by then he/she could achieve an objective character in his/her consciousness. Hence existence of an object in one’s mind is in practice dependent on the subject’s cognitive quality. In this sense a similar understanding of an object or a matter among human sounds like an insensible idea, since there will be unlimited differentiation of the perception towards the matter.
As Bergson further explained, through differentiation, the immediate data of consciousness of being temporal, similarly as the concept of duration. In the duration, there is no juxtaposition of events; therefore there is no mechanistic causality.[11] Duration as introduced by Bergson is a perspective of qualitative multiplicity of grasping things. In contrast with quantitative multiplicity which is evaluating matters through freezing time and considering spatial difference, for instance, we are able to count a flock of birds flying, though they are similar from a distance but we could evaluate one to another because they occupy different space. Qualitative multiplicity freezes spatial dimension and works with time. As he depicted it with the act of drawing a continuous line mimicking an elastic band, the trembling line which is made along making the whole continuous line is a qualitative multiplicity in duration and spatially it is united as a line. Therefore to encounter this concept Bergson further introduce his method of intuition.
Unlike the normal way our intelligence work, which reconstructing of a thing by synthesizing the perspectives which later will yield the concept of things, but never the thing itself, intuition reverses the procedure which is interested and analytic. Bergson himself considered his thought as “the true empiricism.”[12] Intuition is an act entering into ourselves seizing ourselves from within and self-sympathizing heterogeneously into others, using one’s own duration to comprehend other duration, because one’s duration is a real part of the duration itself. Considering one-self authentic perspective to be able to comprehend the world freely and authentically therefore in its disposition it is absolute.  
Bergson’s general idea in Matter and Memory is affirming the reality of the dualism both of matter and spirit, but more than this realism and idealism, our knowledge of things, in its pure state, takes place within the things it represents.
There is no hidden power in matter; matter is only images. The image of a material thing becomes a representation. A representation in one’s mind is always in the image virtually never physically, it never reaches human consciousness as a whole object. There is a transition from the image as being in itself to its being for me. This process adds nothing new to the image, in fact, it subtracts from it, we generally while experiencing or grasping external world tend to attain of what does interest bodily functions in relation with necessity. The conscious perception of a living being therefore exhibits a “necessary poverty” (Matter and Memory, p. 38).
“Intuition is not perception, it is memory”, through memory and continuous heterogeneity of duration, the notion of duality becomes a monism in one’s reality. By the course of perception, it indicates that representation of an object is different than image, image is less than the thing but more than a representation. Perception is therefore a continuous process through and with the images of matter. Accordingly, Bergson is re-attaching perception to the real.

Spatial Form and Spatial Practice
It is undeniably true especially with today’s technological advances we could evaluate space thoroughly. We could calculate, simulate, and predict even reconstruct spatial form with its similar physical qualities, however those advances are methods to quantify and evaluate space in its technical manner, though its impact on space production and creation is extremely influential. In the other point of view, those advances do not change fundamentally how space communicates to us. “Space, and consequently that which encloses it, are much more central to all of us in our everyday lives than purely technical, aesthetic, or even semiotic interpretation would suggest.”[13] As Bryan Lawson put it, not even aesthetic argumentation, understandings, and interpretations of it are taking crucial role in the course of human to be in space. Only by practicing within the spatial form throughout everyday life, a space would receive and reveal its characteristic.

Whatever space and time mean, place and occasion mean more. For space in the image of man is place, and time in the image of man is occasion.
Aldo van Eyck

Before modern and industrial movement each object was linked to some “style” and therefore, as a work, contained while masking the larger functions and structures which were integral parts of its form. In contrast, a modern object clearly states itself for itself, of what it is, its role and its place.[14] This different perspective and method of production is creating or at least appeals with different way for object to represent itself. However still fundamentally this transformation does not change the relationship of form to function to structure, though it speaks differently but the fundamental manner of language is unchanged.
As container of things, space in the same time along with the existence of the things is also possessed with the ideas and systems behind the things. Space is able to contain ideas, systems, and therefore possibilities. Those possibilities are not only available in the space but also creates the space. As it able to convey ideas thus space is most of the time a complex matter, because it could contain several things and hence bunch of ideas.
As Christine Frederick, the lady behind the modern household described her perspective on her practice in home-making, “You men simply don’t understand anything about work in a home. One day a woman sweeps and dusts, and he next she irons, and the next she bakes, and in between-times she cares for babies, and sews, answers call bells and phones, and markets, and mends the lining of her husband’s coat, and makes a cocoa-nut cake for Sunday!”[15] A house especially the kitchen, plays a very crucial role on the process home-making, which was in general practiced by a housewife. It includes as well requires a lot sort of things and set of skills in its practice. There are a lot of variation of kitchen spatial planning available, but in any case the main spatial practice of a kitchen is always about food.
Through her process of practicing the whole kitchen ‘set of spatial practices’ in her everyday pattern, it becomes part of her way of dwelling and her practice of everyday life. She learns, situates herself, tries to be able to do the practice and simultaneously the practice itself keeps on shaping her along the practices.
The everyday can therefore be defined as a set of functions which connect and join together systems that might appear to be distinct. The concept of everydayness does not therefore designate a system but rather a denominator common to existing system.[16] The notion of everyday is a personal quality, a notion which is embedded from person to person, for instance, from knowing what a knife is, when and why using it, trying to learn on how to use it, using it carefully and with full attention, keep on using it without doubt, getting faster on using it, until singing along while using it. As explained by Lefebvre the everyday is not set of system applied on acts, but instead it denominates the activities into mere bodily pattern without the consciousness of doing it, which is banal. By then, “the act is only graspable as a surface of projection (or a ‘veil’ as I prefer it). Itself visible, it has the effect of making invisible the operation that made it possible. These fixations constitute procedures for forgetting. The trace left behind is substituted for the practice. It exhibits the (voracious) property that the geographical system has of being able to transform action into legibility, but in doing so it causes a way of being in the world to be forgotten.”[17]

Unconscious Practice
Based on Anthony Giddens classification of consciousness model in human, most of our knowledge about the world can be seen as knowledge we are practically conscious about. We are able to do things with certain knowledge without being able to report about it. “Actors possess this knowledge without being able to give account on it” (Lippuner et al, 2009, p. 42) which they call it tacit knowledge, of which in it we depend most of our social action in everyday life.
As we move, with the bodily poses and gestures, we are progressively inscribed through body with the structure of social order. Social structures reconverted into physical structures playing in tension between the duality fluctuating, influencing one to another.
The tacit knowledge as Giddens puts it, is a form of social and spatial practice, it insists the knowledge to be passively recorded in contrast with positivist materialism which is constructing the knowledge and as well contrasted with intellectualist idealism which proposing system of structured. But Habitus is constituted in practice and is always oriented towards practical functions. Habitus is inscribed within the everyday life, within real activity in particular place, as a practical relation to the world. To be actively present in the world through which the world imposes its presence, with its urgencies, its things to be done and said, and things made to be said, which directly govern and deeds without ever unfolding as a spectacle.[18]
A rigid structure is implicitly applied in constructing the character of place, defining the objective relationship or signifying the way to live within, and here goes the role of the dwellers to act within the structure, along with his/her self-tendency maintaining between the two, not to be entirely driven by the structure and not to fall to subjectivity, for the later does not always favor the necessity of social world. The merge will happen in the realm of practice, the meeting point of the objectified products (opus operatum) and the incorporated products of historical practice (modus operandi); of structures and habitus.[19]
Practice as it is performed with tacit knowledge it conducts very little consciousness, purposive orientation, and rational calculation. The actor is carried out by the practice, a tacit, informal, and taken for granted degree of awareness. Habitus along with its unaware practice is also localized and spatially diverse, for it is the reflection of the life within the structure.

Reality Determinant
In the scale of everyday life therefore a long term repetition, the applied structure and the bodily pattern of dwelling prompt principles of vision and division, differences between practices, goods which are possessed, opinions which are expressed, those in an extent become symbolic differences and constitute a real language, which ultimately the character of a society and as well the place. Habitus in practice contributes into a very practical detail of the actors, what to eat, the way to eat, the cool attire, the undiscussable topic, the dream of the kids, the song stuck in the head, segment of friendship, notion of good and bad, wrong and right, and so on and so basically is the background of one’s reality. Any of the notion applied derive from the practicing process, which triggered or situated within another system of how to run the practice and another system of how to express them, which is in this sense where spatial property is very crucial and influential on constructing reality.
Assuming the practical world which is now embedded with the notion of habitus, as a system of cognitive and motivating structures, would be a world of already realized ends. The world along with its inherent value expressing what to do, what to enjoy, what to expect, what to wish for, moreover with objects endowed with “permanent teleological character”, in Husserl’s phrase is an institution. An institution is objectified not only in its things, actors and field but also in the disposition to recognize and comply with the demands in the field.[20]

Possibility and Power
Habitus is embedded in one’s dwelling practice is carved through the course of time, it is determined whether it has been practiced and habitually inscribed in one’s life. It is therefore established by past experience and it is continuously altered. In the other hand where this notion becomes vital is in the time of considering the future and therefore the now. Habitus is in itself a universe of probabilities, a set of yes’s and no’s, good and bad, do and don’t, which establishes both consciously and unconsciously the ‘possible now.’
The ‘particular case of the possible’ is situated through the perpetual relationship between dispositions (habitus) and conditions, the ‘possible now’ is yielded without rational calculation or conscious estimation of the chances of success, it is processed through the immediate correspondence between ‘the probability’ flavored on an event and ‘the post probability’ of which are established on the basis of past experience.
The relation to what is possible is a relation to power; and the sense the probable future is constituted in the prolonged relationship with a world structured according to the categories of the possible (for us) and the impossible (of us), of what is appropriated in advance by and for others and what once can personably expect for oneself.[21]
Habitus is undeniably instilled by repetition in practice both actively shaping and being shaped. In the context of ‘possible now’, this disposition suggests one’s capability and reliability on dealing with the current, habitus holds latent potential, which in the ‘possible now’, it is no longer the repetition of practice which matters but rather its reliability when evoked.[22]

Built Environment and Dwelling Practice
Approaching this perspective as a whole, it is certain though implicitly that there is a mutual implication between ‘built environment’ and ‘dwelling practice’, as Rapoport puts it, “first, in the sense that an understanding of behavior patterns, including desires, motivations, and feelings, is essential to the understanding of built form, since built form is the physical embodiment of these patterns; and second, in the sense that forms, once built, affect behavior and the way of life.”[23]
Coming back to Hans van der Laan metaphor of architecture, it suggested that architect is responsible for ‘the between man and space’, which is the ‘built environment’. Once planned-spatial-form is realized in the physical world, it would stand and speak for itself. It will become part of reality, thus it will be practiced, and therefore it would be embedded in certain context and in someone’s life. In my point of view this is a very crucial role of an architect, especially being an architect in a modern and industrialized society which almost has detached entirely the act of dwelling and building, and also being aware of the capacity and the influential or even determining quality of space (built environment) toward its user, draw me to analyze and examine the question of how built environment is embedded in its inhabitant’s dwelling practice. In the sense of being aware and understanding what an architect have planned and applied in the context and in someone’s life, really matters throughout its existence.

The more involved a person is with the form and content of his surroundings, the more those surroundings become appropriated by him, and just as he takes possession of his surroundings, so they will take possession of him.
Herman Hertzberger. Lessons for Students in Architecture (p. 170)



[1] George Herbert Mead. Mind, Self, and Society: From the Standpoint of a Social Behaviorist (ed. C.W.Morris). Chicago: Chicago University Press. 1967, p. 245-246.
[2] Bryan Lawson. The Language of Space. Oxford: Architectural Press. 2001, p. 25.
[3] Herman Hertzberger. Lessons for Students in Architecture. Rotterdam: 010 Publishers. 2005, P. 150.
[4] Pierre Bourdieu. Physical Space, Social Space and Habitus: A Lecture in Sociology Department in University of Oslo. Oslo. 1996, p. 10-13.
[5] Ibid., p. 10.
[6] David L. Swartz. The Occupational Therapy Journal of Research (vol. 22): The Sociology of Habit: The Perspective of Pierre Bourdieu. 2002, p. 65-66.
[7] Hans van der Laan. Architectonic Space. Leiden: Brill. 1983, p. 1.
[8] Lars Lerup. Building the Unfinished: Architecture and Human Action. Michigan: SAGE Publications. 1977, p. 152.
[9] Amos Rapoport. House Form and Culture. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall. 1969, p. 47.
[10] Pierre Bourdieu. Structures, Habitus, Practices, p. 280.
[11] Henri Bergson. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/bergson/. Accessed on January 2016.
[12] Henri Bergson. The Creative Mind: An Introduction to Metaphysics. New York: Dover Publications. 2007, p. 175.
[13] Bryan Lawson. The Language of Space. Oxford: Architectural Press. 2001, p. 6.
[14] Henri Lefebvre. The Everyday and Everydayness. Yale French Studies. 1987, p. 8.
[15] Christine Frederick. The New Housekeeping: Efficiency Studies in Home Management. New York: Doubleday Page & Company. 1913, p. 7.
[16] Henri Lefebvre. The Everyday and Everydayness. Yale French Studies. 1987, p. 9.
[17] Michel de Certeau. The Practice of Everyday Life. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press. 1984, p. 97.
[18] Pierre Bourdieu. Structures, Habitus, Practices, p. 277-278.
[19] Ibid.
[20] Ibid., p. 282.
[21] Ibid., p. 288.
[22] David L. Swartz. The Occupational Therapy Journal of Research (vol. 22): The Sociology of Habit: The Perspective of Pierre Bourdieu. 2002, p. 63.
[23] Amos Rapoport. House Form and Culture. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall. 1969, p. 16.

Monday, February 1, 2016

Informality_beyond slums_DIASS15_ How can formality benefit from informality

...what is the pleasure of acting informal?


ARCHITECTURE OF INFORMALITY
Prof Ivan Kucina
DIA, Dessau, January 2016
student Bojana Bjelic





PLEASURE





  1. (n.) A feeling of happiness or enjoyment /'she smiled with pleasure'/
  2. (n.) What the will dictates or prefers as gratifying or satisfying, hence, will, choice, wish, purpose.
  3. (n.) The gratification of the senses or of the mind; agreeable sensations or emotions; the excitement, relish, or happiness produced by the expectation or the enjoyment of something delightful, or satisfying (not necessarily good)
  4. (n.) Amusement; sport; diversion; self-indulgence; frivolous or dissipating enjoyment; hence, sensual gratification;
    - opposed to labor, service, duty, self-denial, etc. 1




...what is the pleasure of acting informal?




During the last semester, a colleague from the class posted a question that triggered my attention: 'What if we ask chair what does it want to be', what would the chair say? What does the chair actually want to be? And what do we want it to be? Is a chair only to be sit on?

It interested me, because every day when I go out of the building where we study, to drink my coffee and have this little daily routine during the break, that i consider pleasing, I don't find any chairs. I don't even look for chairs, i don't think about them. Without much thinking, I sit on the doorsteps . Because i want to sit and put the coffee down while i roll a cigarette. These concrete doorsteps became part of my daily routine.
Soon people join me, and sit next to me and we talk. On the doorsteps. But this doorsteps are not made to be sit on, or for people to drink coffee on. They are made to allow the entrance to the building – to step to the doors? I finish my coffee and go back inside. Right after the entrance there is another couple of steps taking me down towards the lecture hall. When I think about it, I also used to sit there sometimes...


In the Plato's dialogue Philebus, which is focused on pleasure, he suggests that pleasure is not one thing, but rather there are different kinds of pleasures, from the pleasure that contributes to survival, to the pleasure that guides our choices, to the true pleasure found in pure mathematics.

Another central figure from ancient philosophy, Epicurus, however, rejects the idea that there are many kinds of pleasure, and advances the view that the many pleasures we feel differ only in degree or intensity and so can always be ranked relative to one another.

On Aristotle's view, pleasure is an aspect of activities we undertake, namely, what an activity gains when there is a fit between the capacity being activated, for example, sitting, and what it is activated in relation to, say, chair: we take pleasure in sitting on the chair because there is a good fit between our capacity for sitting and that chair. Our pleasures, then, will be as varied as are our capacities.

But what is a pleasure of acting informal?

There are certain intangible boundaries we are given in language, behaviour, movement, space etc
They are rules, purposes, bans, regulations etc.. If i want to sit and drink coffee, there is a chair to sit on and there is a table to place coffee on while sitting on the chair. But i sit on the concrete doorsteps, and put my coffee on that same concrete surface, and smoke a cigarette which i know is not good for my health but I think it brings me certain pleasure.

'In feeling the pleasure in eating the chocolate cake, we represent the cake as good; in feeling pleasure in reading the novel, we represent that activity as good. So we might think of pleasure as similar to other sensory experiences. Just as our sense of vision represents shapes and colors, and our sense of hearing represents sounds, so does our ability to sense pleasure represent particular things as good for us. When we eat too much cake or become over-engrossed in a novel, we are misrepresenting what is good for us in some way. In these cases by exaggerating the degree to which we feel pleasure in something that is just bad for us: if natural gas were imbued with the smell of roses instead of the smell of sulfur, we could imagine feeling pleasure even while inhaling the dangerous substance.' 2

...so I sit on the doorsteps, and people join me and we sit on the doorsteps, disturb its utilitarian function. But no one told me not to sit on the doorsteps. There is no rule, and no one is actually complaining. They are large doorsteps, there is few of us sitting there so we don't actually disturb their function, since people can still go inside. No one ever complained that we are misusing the doorstep's function.

After sitting on that doorsteps so many times, i really like that place. Right there, on the other side, is a tree, behind the net fence. I was sitting there during the spring with friends, day after day, and one of those spring days we noticed this tree, it was blooming. We were speaking about the tree. What a lovely tree, what a lovely place to sit on and watch this tree while having some discussions after the lecture. One of those days we were also having organised barbecue on the parking in front of a student dorm, right next to that tree.

We enjoyed those moments. It was a pleasure to sit on that staircase and notice that tree blooming and speak about it. It was a pleasure also having that barbecue on the parking lot.


'We find some colors more pleasant than others; as anyone who has spent some time with paint chips can attest, there is difference in the 'feel' of a warm shade of a white and a stark, clinical white. What is happening in these sorts of cases? Are we having two sensations – one of color, and another of pleasure – or just one sensation? It certainly seems as if pleasure is not a separate sensation – one of color. We can't look at certain colors without feeling a pleasure, nor can we feel the pleasure detached from the color. Perhaps, then, pleasure is not so much a sensation as a manner of perceiving.' 2

I guess who ever designed the entrance to that building, or that parking lot next to the student dorm in Bauhausstrasse, didn't predict them as places for someone's pleasure. This pleasure was found in misuse of these spaces. At that time we were very aware that a parking space is not allowed to barbecue on, and that there were places in the city where it is allowed to barbecue.
Still we barbecued there, because it was close to everybody, we had music coming from the dorm and fridges to cool the beers, it was close to school, so also we could go back to our studios to work if we didn't like the barbecue. And actually there was not more that few cars on that quite big parking lot.
And no one ever complained.

'Pleasure can and does mislead us. I take a bit of chocolate cake, savouring the flavour, the texture, the wave of warmth the cocoa brings, and so I take another bite aiming to sustain the feeling of pleasure, and then another bite aiming to sustain the feeling of pleasure, and then another, and then I've overindulged. You become engrossed in a novel, turning page after page after page, enjoying the world unfolding in the book as time passes without notice, but then you find you've neglected to mark papers, make dinner, walk the dog. In these sorts of cases we want to say that pleasure led us astray, but how? Did the pleasure capture us, so that we could do or think of nothing else? This doesn't seem quite right: in eating the cake, I was focused on the texture and the taste as much as the pleasure I felt. In reading a novel, you were thinking of the characters and the narrative, as well as taking pleasure in the story. We feel pleasure along with other experiences we might be having. But still, there is something about pleasure that can gain control of us, and so explain our being misguided.' 2

But what if other people from the town all of a sudden found pleasure in making barbecue on the same parking lot or sitting on the same doorsteps, watching the same tree. Soon probably, no one would be able to enter the building and people would complain. Or after so many barbecues the dorm would constantly smell like coal and burned meet which would disturb the utilitarian function of this building. Students will not be able to study from the noise or smell, they would complain and citizens of the town would loose their place for pleasure. I maybe wouldn't consider the staircase pleasing any more because they would loose the character of misused staircase. Than this would become their function and soon all the seats would be occupied.
They would have to seek for another one. But it would be interesting if everyone wanted to barbecue there. Maybe they would fight for this parking to become a new barbecue area, win, and students would have to find a new dorm.

'We are all familiar with the story in which Adam succumbs to the temptation of pleasure, and eats fruit from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil. Eve is presented as a kind of seductress, enticing Adam to indulge in this pleasure, as has been strictly forbidden by God. This is not Malebranche's story; indeed Eve barely makes an appearance. Malebranche tells the story thus: in the Garden of Eden, Adam felt pleasure all the time, to immediately inform him about what was good for him. With this information coming in directly, he could be directed fully towards God. However, instead of continuing to feel pleasure, in doing so. That is, rather than simply sensing the apple as a vehicle of nourishment. Adam's pleasure transformed as he began to focus on the apple, as an object, with properties to be discovered. For Malebranche, original sin is just noticing things around us in such a way that we are moved to find out more about them, to pursue knowledge. Noticing things in this way involves a particular sort of pleasure, but this sort of pleasure is quite special. It is not simply one manner of perceiving things among many. It is the manner of perceiving things as things. Pleasure is in the awareness of the world around us.' 2

Even though situation like this would never happen, and not everybody would want to sit on that same doorsteps, this story was used just as a metaphor. In reality that little space of the doorsteps stay special only for few of us, who misused it or maybe recognized it's value. It was there, no chairs were around and we discovered that there was a good fit between our 'capacity for sitting' and those doorsteps. And maybe felt a little pleasure in the awareness of the doorsteps being able to host this function that they weren't designed for, and that no one told us could be suitable for, but was somehow offered by its shape, proportions and position in the moment when we needed a place to sit and put coffee down. And the pleasure here is maybe found in the idea that we somehow asked the chair what it wants to be and it said doorsteps.









1 – various meanings of the word 'pleasure' found on google
2 – from the text 'What is pleasure', by Lisa Shapiro, Professor of Philosophy at Simon Fraser University, Canada.



Sunday, January 31, 2016

Is informal architecture only about the settlements or does it consider the 'art of living' too?












      Is informal architecture only about the settlements or does it consider the 'art of living' too?













Architecture Informality
Prof .Ivan Kucina

Student: Sri Charan Petnikota.
College: DIA, Dessau.
Matrikel no : 4060992




“We shape our buildings; thereafter they shape us.” 
                                                                                                                  ― 
Winston Churchill


Most of the dense cities are world’s healthiest places and others are among the worst. Health outcomes are worse among the lower income population in the dense cities and according to statics 30 to 60 percentage are living in such informal settlements. And these is because of the increase in the density of population in the certain area in cities. Dense Cities are developed because of the high density people are there for growth of industry, trade and services. These advantages can reinforce large and economically successful cities but at the same time as health for people remains very poor. For instance, City like Mumbai is very successful but it also has one half of the population lives in high dense informal settlements which may take up small portion of land in the city but there is no provision for water, sanitation, drainage and health care. These case are true in most of metropolitan cities like Cairo, Egypt and cities in Africa. In cities like Nairobi and Karachi more than half the population of the city live in informal settlements that take up only few percent of city’s land area.

High density informal densities have benefits for residents, these settlements are near to their work place. So time and cost of travelling is saved. Dharavi in Mumbai is one biggest slums in the Asia which is located in the center of Mumbai indeed provides easy and time saving  access to work place but not only that ,it also to services in cities that makes city special like theaters , music ,venues ,museums ,libraries , the visual arts, dance ,festivals ,the enjoyment of historic buildings and districts . Dharavi is most popular place to live among low income groups not because of the health advantages but because of economic advantages which result for large earning opportunities there. These people don’t want to move near city periphery where land rates may be cheaper and more space available because it brings high costs in time and money getting to and from work.

Many of the most desirable and expensive residential districts in European cities are also high density area, often with three to six storey buildings. High income groups choose to live in such areas because of the quality of life that is present there. In very high-density settings, the trade-off between indoor space, space for transport, public and private open spaces such as squares, parks and gardens and space for public amenities is complex.

Urban poverty and house transformation effects living condition of the people in informal settlements:
 Urban poverty is usually defined as the lack of income required meeting defined needs such as adequate diet, health care, and education. In spatial terms, urban poverty can be as inadequate access to infrastructure and services.

In real life context, households may move in and out of poverty by organizing and managing the human, physical, financial, natural and social assets at their knowledge. The concept of resistance, which is more dynamic than poverty, is capable of capturing the change processes whereby households move in and out of poverty. And vulnerability is closely linked to the concept of livelihoods that are defined as the means of gaining a living utilizing the different assets as resources.

Inside the structure of livelihoods, how and why owner households transform their houses and the consequences on the settlement structure in the particular context of informal settlements, where the majority of low-income earners live and where legal development control is lacking.

Usually in developing countries like India, Pakistan owner households transform their houses in order to improve their livelihoods including the provision of space for the second generation members to “live”. Housing transformation is also a key strategy for shelter delivery. The housing transformation process is incremental and strongly linked to the assets at the disposition of the households at any particular time.

The main negative effects of housing transformation are excessive densification together with overcrowding and public health problems, occupational health hazards and settlement degradation through road blockades.

“When housing transformations are not guided, their negative effects undermine the livelihoods of the owner households”.
People in informal settlements build their own livelihoods on their resource talents of skills, abilities, land, savings, and equipment by support of formal or informal groups and networks that enable them to sustain a certain level of living standards. The level of supply of resources talents has a bearing not only on how individuals are protected and fed, but also subsequently on their health status. It is observed in the informal settlements that children of parents with more education, skills and abilities are more likely to have better health outcomes .Education also place an important role to maintain health of the family and oneself in the formal settlements.
The health and livelihood concerns of slum dwellers seem to be diverse yet tangled; they are faced with poor access to safe and adequate drinking water, and poor sanitary facilities - which pre-dispose them to illnesses. In the event of illness, they have limited access to appropriate health services due to both physical Health and Livelihood Needs of Residents of Informal Settlements and financial barriers, resulting mainly from limited livelihood opportunities. To address their health concerns focusing on single interventions such as curative or preventive would probably be less effective because the approach would ignore the contentedness of their problems. Child illness and mortality is the greatest health challenge in these slum communities. This implies that intervention packages that address health service provision, environmental sanitation, personal hygiene, health seeking behavior, and livelihood opportunities are likely to have greater impact.


Informal Settlements and the Environment.

Informal settlements have often viewed as a source of pollution and disease. Lack of service provision, in particular sewer systems, refuse, and collection, and water supply, means that conditions are unsanitary. Household waste is generally abandoned into open streams, and downstream inhabitants suffer as a result. Rodents and insects often proliferate. In South Africa during the early years of the 20th century, such conditions were used to justify the eviction and segregation of non-white communities from cities like Johannesburg. Nairobi was also racially segregated, a policy rationalized as a means of achieving “a disease-free environment with a minimum of public expenditure. “This ‘environmental health’ narrative has been mobilized against poor Communities in other African countries, even in recent years. And for example Kibera is an informal settlement which had thirteen villages in south of Nairobi where according to the statics one million people live without electricity and proper sewerage. Toilets are holes in the ground and portable is hard to get and expensive. While it’s raining the situation gets worse. The settlements that they live in doesn’t provide opportunity for healthy life style because of their economic and social situations.

Creativity in Informality Settlements.

Informal settlements promotes certain level of platform for practicing the art. It plays an essential role in creative dynamics and vitalization processes. Urban creativity was based on misbehavior and investigation of the alternative. These process develop on edge of the formality and on the challenge of conventional solution. Graffiti, street art or other urban interventions have brought us many examples of these in recent years. These processes naturally bring important conflicts of uses between city users, both in material and symbolic arenas. These conflicts of interest, expressed in public and private spaces, are often associated to strong gentrification processes. Non-formal, non-sanitized spaces are particularly attractive to the development of creative dynamics. For some of the start-up artist who are economically not sound staying in the informal settlements provides a podium for them to practice their arts on the streets and enhance their skills.

User-Created Atmospheres.

The features of these neighborhoods that are most relevant is that locally developed neighborhoods are often well organized internally; they develop through courses that can be recognized, they are often constructed in a professional manner; and they have a tendency to improve over time. They usually are home to discriminated castes and communities, who improve their living standard incrementally, in line with the neighborhood's own urban development. The concepts of home-grown neighborhoods and neighborhoods in-formation as an entry point for policy, planning, and architectural engagements based on the recognition of local dynamics, developmental processes, and emerging forms. The neighborhood mentioned above have all been developed by masons, carpenters, plumbers and electricians who live and work within the locality. For the most part, they are built of hard industrial material such bricks, steel, cement, and plaster of Paris. This gives an interesting twist to the notion of ‘vernacular architecture’, since the techniques and labor are local but the materials are part of a global market. The small footprint of houses means that they can fairly easily be rebuilt with improved material and designs. Thus these neighborhoods characteristically improve over time, both in small increments and over longer phases.

Informality as Resistance.

 “By leaving the people to build or organize their markets informally, the government is able to accuse them of violating laws and regulations at any time. It is an indirect way to control as well as a way to reduce people’s demands and expectations of quality services, because they are informal.” So can we begin to think of informality not only as a way of survival or resistance but as a way to control?
-Dr. Khaled Abdelhalm.

In cities like Cairo and Mumbai the authorities give the opportunity in informal settlements to create their own place for certain function like markets and sometimes house also in the case of Istanbul and accuse them of violating the laws so that they don’t expect any other services from the government and they control the settlements. Which adversely effects on the life style of the people as they tend to fear to change certain things in their settlements and also in their own life style. The ways in which informal urban spaces are imagined, successfully constructed or ultimately disintegrate reflect degrees of competency and literacy in community organisation, in framing a cohesive and ‘deserving’ discourse and in the actual dialogue with local and national expressions of power .

Major effects of Living condition of people in informal settlements.

The extensive of poorly controlled settlement developments has resulted in many environmental and health related problems. Uncontrolled settlement development is causing physical disorder, uneconomical land utilization, and excessive encroachment of settlements into good agricultural land, environmental degradation and pollution risks

 The most common consequences of the informal settlements include the following:

Pollution of Water Sources:

Expansion of the informal human settlements has been the major cause for pollution of ground water sources, most of which are located on the periphery of the Town. Loss of vegetation around water sources reduces water flow while poor disposal of liquid and solid wastes causes water pollution .There have been frequent outbreaks of water borne diseases like cholera and dysentery, particularly during high rainfall seasons, due to contamination of the drinking water.

Deforestation:

Natural forests and catchment areas are being invaded by the expanding human settlements. The ongoing shrinkage Towns due to the expansion of settlements. This practice has reduced the amount of ground water and resulted in environmental degradation.

Pollution from Solid and Liquid Wastes:

One of the fundamental problems faced by the residents of Town is the lack of a proper system for waste management. The problem is even more severe in the informal settlement areas. Due to the lack of established collection points, piles of garbage are scattered in and around residential areas which leads to environmental and health problems. Few residents opt to bury or burn their wastes close to their residences. As there is no centralized sewage system, liquid waste which includes water from washing, laundry, kitchen, bath and other domestic uses is haphazardly discharged onsite. This disposal practice pollutes the groundwater and marine environments and is a major cause of water borne diseases.

Flooding:

Haphazard construction of houses has blocked many natural water ways and has led to frequent floods during the rainy seasons particularly in the months of March, April and May of every year. Soil erosion and landslides are strongly related to flooding which destroy houses as well as footpaths and unpaved roads. Houses and other properties are being washed away by floods forcing the inhabitants to vacate the areas. A high housing density, which most of the informal settlements are characterized by, makes natural seepage of storm water more difficult due to a high share of sealed land. Flooding which results in the overflow of pit latrines and septic tanks is also a major cause for pollution of water sources and marine environments. Due to the non-existence of drainage systems, storm water creates big puddles that become breeding places for mosquitoes which is the cause of malaria.

Encroachment of Good Agricultural Land:

The uncontrolled expansion of human settlements has led to conversion of the best agricultural land into settlements. There have been genuine complaints that the agricultural land is consistently decreasing due to over expansion of human settlements. This trend has not been reversed as more and more people are flocking into urban areas to look for what is perceived as a better life. The loss of agricultural land means a decrease of crop production and income of poor agricultural families.

Accessibility:

Lack of access is one of the most common problems caused by and experienced by residents in the informal settlements. Because there are neither the layout plans nor the regulatory machinery, residents tend to build to almost 100 per cent of their plot size. It has become impossible to provide access roads to these areas as there is no space for this. Likewise, no area is left open for social services like schools, hospitals, children’s play grounds, etc. Consequently, people and service movement in these areas is very restricted and residents have to walk long distance to obtain services like health, education, transport .


Illegal occupation of urban land and their Problems.

It is a widespread phenomenon in many metropolitan city like Mumbai, Cairo. Inner city slum dwellers, although occupying land outside the legal land tenure system with limited or no access to public utilities, benefit from their proximity to formal and informal employment in downtown areas. Illegal settlements in central areas create problems such as poor living conditions for the settlers and negative environmental and social impacts on the rest of populace, particularly those that utilize the central areas.

From the city’s perspective key problems include: higher than average incidence of wastes and odors in the settlements and surrounding neighborhoods; discontinuities of street structure resulting from many settlements situated in the right of way of planned roads; overcrowding of downtown urban services by the settlers. From the settlers’ perspective, key problems in downtown areas are similar to those of periphery settlements, except that downtown settlements have higher densities, thus posing a more complex and costly implementation challenge. Therefore, there is a need to both promote the social and economic advancement of slum dwellers and eliminate negative externalizes that affect the entire city. The programs required to address these situations are multi-sector and difficult to implement. However, the integrated interventions of settlement-upgrading programs in central areas generate significant urban benefits for the area as a whole, along with substantial improvements in living conditions for the beneficiaries, supporting the argument that such interventions are better conceptualized as urban development programs and that their overall economic benefits help justify their above average costs .


Conclusion:


From analysis the findings, Facts, statistics and research papers it can be said that the art of living in informal settlements depends on wide number of things like economic ,social , community, government , Services in the area , Individual perception ,education and so on. Informal settlements are not just about the settlement’s but it considers art of living or in other words the art of living depends on the condition that community is facing in the informal settlements. The life style of the people are molded according to the circumstances of the settlements. There is huge opportunities in this sector to improve the health condition and life style of the people with help of Ngo, Community and Government.

The trade-offs between living space and public amenities for any informal settlements upgrade are complex. These initiatives share a commitment by city governments to work with all the residents and their community organisations to seek the best workable compromise. This is much easier for governments in cases where representative organisations have been formed by those living in informal settlements and want to work with them, as is the case with the national and city federations of slum or shack dwellers that are active in nations. This is especially so when city governments work with those living in informal settlements to take advantage of their agglomeration economies and provide the infrastructure and services that can transform health and quality of life.

Working with communities to identify the road ahead can contribute to a socially cohesive approach within informal settlements. Evaluators should move on from passive acceptance of the situation to active engagement to drive toward meaningful solutions. Evaluators have a unique set of skills, and are well placed to find and facilitate solutions to the urbanization process typified within informal settlements. Taking a holistic, strategic approach, we can bring all issues together and focus on improving lifestyle in the informal settlements.

Bibliography:

  • Working Paper of Urbanisation & the Production of Knowledge: The Case of Informality by Andrew Wade in UCl, London.

  • Policy Brief: approaches to informal urban settlements in Africa: experiences from Kigali and Nairobi - by judi wakhungu, chris huggins, elvin nyukuri and jane lumumba.

  • Research on Occupy urban space:  Dialectic of formality and informality in Greece in the era of crisis by Tsavdaroglou Ch. & Makrygianni V. Phd Candidates, Department of Urban and Regional Planning, School of Architecture, Faculty of Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessalonik .

  • Paper on the causes and consequences of the informal settlements in zanzibar 
mohammed haji ali and muhammad salim sulaiman, Tanzania in Shaping the Change XXIII FIG Congress Munich, Germany, October 8 – 13, 2006 .

  • The Ideologies of Informality: informal urbanisation in the architectural and planning discourses Jan Van Ballegooijen & Roberto Rocco published online: 16 Dec 2013.

  • Paper on Settings, Collectivises, Informalities:  Art and Public Space in Istanbul by Can ataly, Istanbul University.

  • Postcolonialising informality by Ann Varley Department of Geography UCL (University College London).

  • Health and Livelihood Needs of Residents of Informal Settlements in Nairobi City, Occasional Study Report 2002 by African Population and Health Research Centre (APHRC).



  • Working Paper by matias echanove (The University of Tokyo) Beyond the Informal: Reconceptualising Mumbai‘s urban development.

  • Dissonant Architecture, Architectures of Dissidence:  On the Right to Urban Society by adrian parr (university of Cincinnati).

  • Upgrading dense informal settlements: the potential for health and well-being by David Satterthwaite is a Senior Fellow at the International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED).