Thursday, January 28, 2016

Informal settlements - Boon or Bane?
























Architecture of Informality
Informal settlements - Boon or Bane?




















Jacob George 
4060847
DIA
Guided by Prof. Ivan Kucina
















Prelude

At the entrance to Cama Chambers, a building in Bombay, hangs this prominent notice:

ATTENTION
This building is unsafe and likely to collapse. Persons entering the property do so at their own risk. The owner of the property will not be liable for any damage to life and property. 
Owners 

If you go up the narrow wooden steps, you can see the signboards of the offices in the unsafe building. They are law firms, accountants, merchant bankers. The offices themselves are sleek, modern, air-conditioned, with computers blinking and flashing. Only the building’s public areas are decrepit. Gaping holes mark the first floor where windows should be. The same notice is posted by the owners on the first floor. They are getting, by force of law, almost nothing in rent for their land. So they will put nothing into repairs of the building; all they can do is put up these cautionary signs, which they hope will frighten away the clients of the businesses within.

This is the case in a lot of Informal buildings around the world. Nobody knows when they were built or when it will come down.

The notion of what is a luxury and what is a basic need has been upended in Bombay. Every slum has a television; antennas sprout in silver branches above the shanties. Many in the middle-class slum have motorcycles, even cars. People in Bombay eat relatively well, too, even the slum dwellers. The real luxuries are running water, clean bathrooms, and transport and housing fit for human beings. It doesn’t matter how much money you have. If you live in the suburbs, you’ll either curse in your car, as you drive for two hours each way toward the centre, or asphyxiate in the train compartments, even the first-class ones. 

The greatest luxury of all is solitude.

A city this densely packed affords no privacy. Those without a room of their own don’t have space to be alone, to defecate or write poetry or make love. A good city ought to have that; it ought to have parks or beaches where young people can kiss without being overwhelmed by the crowd. 
 - Suketu Mehta, Maximum City.
Introduction

For the first time in our history, a half of the worlds population are living in cities. It is high time the Urban Age turned its attention to its cities. An increasing number of India’s population are rushing to urban centres across the subcontinent, with over 300 million city dwellers making up one tenth of the world’s urban population.

In contrast, it is also estimated that a third of the world’s population will by living in slums in the next two decades. This comparison is quite alarming, as it implies that the growth of the slum population is directly proportional to the growth of the city. In the next twenty years, one in every six people would be living in a slum, bringing the number of slum dwellers to a drastic 2 billion people. Slums and cities together contain large parts of Informal settlements and therefore these topics are directly related to our scope of study. 

Informal settlements although should not be confused with slums alone. Though slums are definitely the most extreme of conditions. A large number of towns and cities for that matter are informal, which mean that they have developed over time without any formal planning. We need to understand the complexity within the various layers of Informal settlements.

Rapid urbanisation places remarkable strain on housing and serviced land. By 2030, about 3 billion people, or about 40 per cent of the world’s population, will need proper housing and access to basic infrastructure and services such as water and sanitation systems. This translates into the need to complete 96,150 housing units per day with serviced and documented land from now till 2030.

Now this may come as a surprise, but India is not an overpopulated country. Its population density is lower than that of many other countries not thought of as overpopulated. In 1999, Belgium had a population density of 130 people per square mile; the Netherlands, 150; India, under 120. 

It is the cities of India that are over-populated. 

Singapore has a density of 2,535 people per square mile; Berlin, the most crowded European city, has 1,130 people per square mile. The island city of Bombay in 1990 had a density of 17,550 people per square mile. Some parts of central Bombay have a population density of 1 million people per square mile. This is the highest number of individuals massed together at any spot in the world. They are not equally dispersed across the island. Two-thirds of the city’s residents are crowded into just 5 percent of the total area, while the richer or more rent-protected one-third monopolise the remaining 95 percent.

In India, the greater Bombay region has an annual deficit of 45,000 houses a year. The amount of new construction every year comes up to less than half the number needed. Thus these 45,000 households every year need to be accommodated elsewhere. In the words of the planners, their shelter needs “are satisfied in the informal market.” This population doubles every decade. There are also 400,000 empty residences in the city, empty because the owners are afraid of losing them to tenants if they rent them out. Assuming each apartment can house a family of five people, on average, that’s 2 million people—one fourth of the homeless—who could immediately find shelter if the laws were to be amended.

“Slums are the problem of failed policies, governance, corruption in appropriated regulations, dysfunctional land markets, unresponsive financial system and fundamental lack of political will.” Arif Hasan (An urban architect, activist social researcher and writer) 

In some cities, up to 80 per cent of the population lives in slums. Fifty-five million new slum dwellers have been added to the global population since 2000. Sub-Saharan Africa has a slum population of 199.5 million, South Asia 190.7 million, East Asia 189.6 million, Latin America and the Caribbean 110.7 million, Southeast Asia 88.9 million, West Asia 35 million and North Africa 11.8 million.

Slums are a clear manifestation of a poorly planned and managed urban sector and, in particular, a malfunctioning housing sector. Each day a further 120,000 people are added to the populations of Asian cities, requiring the construction of at least 20,000 new dwellings and supporting infrastructure. In Latin America and the Caribbean current housing needs are estimated at between 42 million and 52 million dwellings, respectively. Estimates concerning total housing needs in Africa have been set at around 4 million units per year with over 60 per cent of the demand required to accommodate urban residents.

Understanding the necessity is the key to any design.



Suketu Mehta gives a vivid description about the slums in Mumbai in his “Maximum City”. 

Much of the slum is a garbage dump. The sewers, which are open, run right between the houses, and children play and occasionally fall into them. They are full of a blue-black iridescent sludge. When the government sweepers come to clean the drains, they scoop it out and leave piles of it outside the latrines. I couldn’t use the public toilets. I tried, once. There were two rows of toilets. Each one of them had masses of shit, overflowing out of the toilets and spread liberally all around the cubicle. For the next few hours that image and that stench stayed with me, when I ate, when I drank. It’s not merely an aesthetic discomfort; typhoid runs rampant through the slum and spreads through oral—fecal contact. Pools of stagnant water, which are everywhere, breed malaria. Many children also have jaundice. Animal carcasses are spread out on the counters of the butcher shops, sprinkled with flies like a moving spice. The whole slum is pervaded by a stench that I stopped noticing after a while.

“Recognising the need is the primary condition for design.”   -Charles Eames

Even after somebody clears a slum colony, it will promptly be rebuilt with substandard material in the same place. “Settlement colonies cannot really be destroyed. They will reappear.” A slum was once determined to clear a section of footpath in Mahim of the slums built on top of it. Every time he would knock them down and leave, they would be rebuilt in hours. “We used to clear them twice, three times a day. They would keep reappearing. They would run away behind the railway tracks and come back after they left.”

















Understanding Informal Settlements and Slums


As per the Oxford Dictionary, informal settlements are a place where people decide to live and build temporary shelters, often followed by more permanent houses. Sometimes informal settlements are supplied with water, electricity, etc. and people can become owners of individual pieces of land. This would mean that slums are just an extreme condition within the definition of an informal settlement.

Informal settlements vary from slums to thriving towns that have just developed informally. While slums house the poorest of any society, informal towns are hosts to people from various financial backgrounds. Slums are a result of bad governance, lack of empathy, corruption. Therefore slums are created out of necessity, just as an informal town, but the difference is that since slums house the poorest of the poor, the land is usually wasteland that nobody is really bothered about, the government or the people. This is obviously because these inhabitants do not have the money to buy land for themselves. There are no sanitation, drainage, waste disposal facilities as these people barely get by with their lives, with their first objective being to provide their families with a meal a day. Therefore these other issues mentioned above are the least of their problems. 

But as discussed, Informal settlements do not always mean slums. There are towns that are informal like Varanasi, that are developed informally, but is legitimate in every way. These cities have been created by architects, engineers and contractors and yet there is a lack of planning in these developments. 


The World Bank recently flew in a group of experts to solve Bombay’s sanitation crisis. The bank’s solution was to propose building 100,000 public toilets. It was an absurd idea. I have seen public latrines in the slums. None of them work. People defecate all around the toilets, because the pits have been clogged for months or years. To build 100,000 public toilets is to multiply this problem hundredfold. 

Maintaining public areas is of the biggest challenges in Informal settlements.

There is a general lack of civic sense.  The boundary of the space you keep clean is marked at the end of the space you call your own. The apartments are spotlessly clean inside; they are swept and mopped every day, or twice every day. The public spaces—hallways, stairs, lobby, the building compound—are stained with betel spit; the ground is littered with congealed wet garbage, plastic bags, and dirt of human and animal origin.

Restaurants are another concern in Informal settlements. On a busy street you can find make-shift restaurants at night and you can see them mysteriously vanish during the day. These restaurants are usually almost full as they provide for the common man and hence are usually dirty, attracting insects and dogs. 

But there are similar restaurants in similar scenarios that thrive in their business. They happen to work as a meeting point for various people when people may gossip about a days work or talk some serious politics. These are among the most dynamic places in a city, full of life and energy. 

The clientele of the restaurants come from immigrant labourers in the city, who lived eight in a room and needed cheap basic meals.

“We have a special problem as planners in Bombay,” says Rahul Mehrotra. “If we make the city nice, with good roads, trains, and accommodation—if we make the city a nicer place to live—it attracts more people from the outside.” Then the city’s screwed up again, from too many people. It’s like building roads. The more roads you build, the greater the number of new cars that will rush in to use those roads, and then they’re jammed again. “Planning in India has to take into account the whole country, the rest of the cities.” Unless entry to Bombay is restricted, it’s an exercise in futility to make this a more liveable city. The number of people in the slums will continue to swell, all the more so if they think they can get off the train and be housed by the government.

But these are the sharp focus landmarks in the daunting world of slums and hostels geared towards single male migrants and the huge red-light areas that cater for them.

In Mumbai, a city in which water and power are erratic, in which the suburban
railway network is so overcrowded that commuters who fall off the trains are killed
every day, the private sector has been asked to create alternative forms of settlements that can provide solutions. All this is occurring in a highly centralised political context where, even though the councillors of Mumbai’s Municipal Corporation are locally elected, the state still holds ultimate control. Other liberal attempts to deal with Mumbai’s chronic overcrowding, its constrained site and continuing attraction to rural migrants have also been questioned, including the issue of the city’s 300,000 street vendors, of whom just a few thousand are licensed. Yet of the 12 million residents of Greater Mumbai, almost 6.5 million live in slums. Mumbai’s slums are of two kinds: the authorised, for which the municipal authority has a responsibility to provide basic services, and the unauthorised, which are subject to demolition, and for which there is no duty for the city to provide power or water. There are impossible densities, 80,000 people per km2  in Dharavi, the largest of the slums. Authorised slums are outnumbered by the 60 per cent that are illegal. Some of the illegals rely on unauthorised standpipes, and a few have no water at all.

The sluggish growth in manufacturing employment in urban areas can also be attributed to the location of large units outside the municipal limits. This is due in part to the impact of the environment lobby in big cities that has campaigned against the dangers of pollution in urban areas. Industrial dispersal in non-urban areas is likely to continue due the availability of land and access to unorganised labour markets, as well as less awareness of the environmental agenda and less stringent implementation of environmental regulations in peripheral areas. As a result, the poor will continue to be pushed to out to these ‘degenerated peripheries’ and commute to the city for jobs in the industries driven out of the central areas. The middle and professional classes, however, are likely to stay in the inner city. This segmented structure of demographic growth could divert prospective migrants to the urban peripheries, swollen by increasing numbers of evicted urban slum dwellers.
Empirical evidence suggests that the profile of the emerging informal sector will be different from the recent past, experiencing a degree of formalisation
resulting from regular forms of employment. Employers and entrepreneurs seeking to take advantage of increasingly global markets have come to recognise that they
would loose their competitive edge unless they standardise their products to meet the specifications of the customers and respect delivery schedules. As a result, they are seeking to establish a degree of ‘formalisation within the informal sector’. Most of the rapidly growing businesses in Indian cities engaged in small-scale manufacturing, trade, commerce and finance that have direct or indirect global linkages are beginning to employ workers on a more regular basis.
Furthermore, professionals working in global businesses, who work long hours, are
increasingly searching for higher levels of certainty in their living arrangements in order to meet the demanding job requirements. As a result, domestic help and other supporting household services are likely to follow a similar process of regularisation.

This process of ‘formal informalisation’ has several other implications. Many of the
rural migrants, lacking in basic levels of literacy, communication skills or market
awareness will find it increasingly difficult to get a foothold in the more demanding urban job market. Consequently, urban India faces a paradox. Despite unprecedented growth in employment, it will continue to experience high levels of unemployment in the future, especially at the heart of its cities. The decline in real wages of casual urban workers in the five-year period 1999–2004, among both men and women, further questions the benefits of this growth on the informal workforce. There has also been a decline in real wages of regular workers in the formal employment sector who seem to be missing out on the benefits of globalisation. Only a fraction of the total labour force in India, made up of educated professional classes, has been able to maintain their real wages. Local governments in many of the Indian cities are currently facing two serious problems in attracting foreign and national businesses and investment. The first is the land scarcity in inner city areas, especially in prime urban locations. The second is lack of capital. Many cities employ ingenious planning and fiscal methods to attract companies, in an attempt to solve this double problem. The Floor Space Index (FSI), which regulates the level of high- density development allowed in the central areas for commercial offices and
high-income residential units, is designed to promote vertical growth in high land-value areas. The aim is to provide much needed space for businesses and, at the same time, generate resources to pay for improvements in infrastructure by selling the extra FSI – or, in other words, allowing much higher levels of development to pay for public infrastructure. In addition, increased FSI is being required by more and more companies since the sanctioning of loans by the international agencies are becoming contingent on the acceptance of higher FSI in city centre areas. The impact of these regulations on the levels of density and the skyline of Indian cities is becoming very apparent.






Relative Contribution of Informal Settlements to Society
Dharavi, Mumbai


Dharavi is one of the world's biggest slums, and one of the most notorious. Look beyond the stereotype, however, and you'll find a successful settlement with a vibrant community and economy. A community that has an annual turnover of 600 Million USD. But developers want to raze it all and start again. Dharavi is a model that should be replicated, not redeveloped.

Located in the heart of Mumbai, Dharavi has a population of more than 600,000 people residing in 100,000 makeshift homes, and one of the world's highest population densities at more than 12,000 persons per acre. It is just across from the Bandra- Kurla Complex, a fast developing commercial centre that has overtaken Nariman Point, the current downtown of Mumbai – and is also located close to Mumbai's domestic and international airports. Despite its plastic and tin structures and lack of infrastructure, Dharavi is a unique, vibrant, and thriving 'cottage' industry complex, the only one of its kind in the world.

This is in fact the kind of self-sufficient, self-sustaining 'village' community that Mahatma Gandhi, the Father of the Nation, dreamt of and wrote about in his books on India's path to development.

Dharavi pulsates with intense economic activity. Its population has achieved a unique informal "self-help" urban development over the years without any external aid. It is a humming economic engine. The residents, though bereft of housing amenities, have been able to lift themselves out of poverty by establishing thousands of successful businesses. A study by Center for Environmental Planning & Technology indicates that Dharavi currently has close to 5,000 industrial units, producing textiles, pottery and leather, and performing services like recycling, printing, and steel fabrication.

A unique characteristic of Dharavi is its very close work-place relationship. 

Productive activity takes place in nearly every home. As a result, Dharavi's economic activity is decentralised, human scale, home-based, low-tech and labor-intensive. This has created an organic and incrementally developing urban form that is pedestrianised, community-centric, and network-based, with mixed use, high density low-rise streetscapes. This is a model many planners have been trying to recreate in cities across the world. A simplistic re-zoning and segregating of these activities, common in the United States, would certainly hurt this very unique urban form.

The 'unplanned' and spontaneous development of Dharavi has led to the emergence of an economic model characterised by a decentralised production process relying mainly on temporary work and self-employment. The multiplicity of independent producers makes the production process extremely flexible and adaptable. Its viability is proven by the national and international market its products command.

Unfortunately , Dharavi is depicted as a 'slum' that lacks residential infrastructure (roads, housing with individual toilets, public conveniences, etc.). In fact it is not a residential slum, but a unique self-contained township (in the sense of close work-place relationship so eulogised since the days of Patrick Geddes, but which has never been achieved in any of the new towns). Because of all these community-based successes, Dharavi needs to be replicated (albeit with adequate physical infrastructure). Instead, the state government wants to force the relocation of Dharavi's population into tiny cubby hole apartments in high rise towers so that the vacated land can be commercially exploited by developers through the Dharavi Redevelopment Plan. At a conservative estimate, a development of this magnitude could fetch $460 million for a developer, a profit of at least 900%.

The truth though is that there is no such thing as a rich 'slum'. Whatever economic output Dharavi produces gets annulled with the deplorable living conditions and human development. Being rich does not only mean creating economic output. There is one toilet in Dharavi for every 1440 inhabitants, that's lower than many parts of sub-Saharan Africa. 

I am not sure if the net impact of Dharavi to Mumbai's economy can easily be estimated too because there are many unobservables involved as well. We know how much Dharavi produces per year but we cannot estimate how much Mumbai loses every year because of healthcare subsidies or overall loss of efficiency because of the hundreds of diseases spread through open defecation by Dharavi residents in the Mahim river and elsewhere.

Dharavi can be a great example of a self-sustained development in an architectural sense, but in terms of humane living conditions, it is the sad reality of the common man in a developing country. 
Conclusion

Today there is a new type of informal economy that is part of advanced capitalism. This in turn explains the particularly strong growth and dynamism of informal economies in global cities. It contributes to explain a mostly overlooked development.

The proliferation of an informal economy of creative professional work in these cities,
i.e. artists, architects, designers, software developers. The growth of this new informal economy is also happening in cities of the global south. In those cases, however, the new is often submerged under the older informal economy. The new types of informalisation of work are the low cost equivalent of formal deregulation. The latter has occurred in finance, telecommunications and most other
economic sectors in the name of flexibility and innovation. The difference is that while formal deregulation was costly, and tax revenue as well as private capital went into paying for it, informalisation is low-cost. It is largely enacted on the backs of more vulnerable workers and their households.

In Karachi, which is the largest of the case study cities (presently at over 13 million inhabitants), has more than half of its population living in squatter settlements, or illegally developed informal settlements. It was discovered that this is primarily due to the fact that the formal sector was not able to meet the annual growth in housing needs (estimated at 80,000 units), the result was, therefore an increase in katchi abadis[5], and illegal subdivisions or densification in inner city areas (through the illegal construction of multi-storey dwellings. Yet due to the fact that this is such a long-established practice, dating back to the days of partition from India in 1947, that there are a lot of good quality houses which are developed in these informal settlements, and so, the local governmental bodies have earmarked some 70 percent of these settlements for regularisation. This means that there will be a provision of a 99-year lease and the development of infrastructure by the local government against a payment to the state.

Architecture cannot be understood without some knowledge of the society it serves - Sir Hugh maxwell. 

Yes, there was a building planned nearby to resettle the slum dwellers. But people from her neighbourhood wouldn’t move there. “There’s too much aloneness. A person can die behind the closed doors of a flat and no one will know. Here,” she observed with satisfaction, “there are a lot of people.” Be it ever so humble. . . . We tend to think of a slum as an excrescence, a community of people living in perpetual misery. What we forget is that out of inhospitable surroundings, the people have formed a community, and they are as attached to its spatial geography, the social networks they have built for themselves, the village they have re-created in the midst of the city. Any urban redevelopment plan has to take into account the curious desire of slum dwellers to live closely together. A greater horror than open gutters and filthy toilets, to the people, is the empty room in the big city.

A city has to take the long view, the view for the common good. - Amanda Burden.

More often than not, these informal settlements are lively and dynamic spaces. Informal spaces bring out the true character and emotions of a society. They often reflect the culture and tradition of a particular town or city. Formal settlements usually are in new cities and towns, where modernity has caught on and hence is the future of a particular society and has nothing to show about its history. Of course that does not mean  that it is not good to look at the future but that is the very point of this comparison, to make it clear that the informal is as important as the formal, in helping a society remain in touch with its true nature.

As of today, it is almost impossible to do away with informal settlements because India is yet a developing country and there are bigger issues at hand than formalising every settlement. But apart from the fact that it cannot be done now, the point is that formalisation should not be done at any point in the future. Informal settlements definite cities and societies. Informal settlements make cities unique and personal and break away from the formal settlements that follow a similar language internationally. Informal cities hold the link between a modern society and its culture and tradition. Informal settlements give identity to their country.

“There’s a plague of sameness that is killing human joy”
Zita Cobb, Shorefast foundation.








References

Mehta, Suketu; Maximum City - Bombay Lost and Found (2004)
U.N. Habitat; State of the World’s Cities 2012/2013
U.N. Habitat; State of the World’s Cities 2006/2007
Apte, Prakash M; Planitizen



































Jacob George
DIA

4060847

Wednesday, January 20, 2016

Funding for informal urban projects



Introduction

In the last decade, the contribution of citizens and civic society actors to urban development has become integrated into the spatial policies of many industrialised cities. This essay gives a broad overview of the means by which these informal urban actors can finance their projects in the context of industrialised countries. The concept of informality in the region is identified, as well as the role the built environment professionals (architects, urbanists) play within it. Then a brief overview of funding categories through project examples is presented. These different funding categories are further discussed in terms of the level of formalisation they demand and conditions they impose on the informal urban actors and their projects. While traditional government funding has a lot more conditions attached to it, new less-restrictive forms of foundation and civil-society funding are now increasingly becoming available to more recognised urban actors.

Informal urban development in industrialised nations

According to (Oswalt et al., 2013: 8) the classical discussion and interest in urban informality can be traced back to writings of 1960s and 1970s. For example Learning form Las Vegas by Robert Ventury and Denise Scott Brown (1972), or Delirious New York by Rem Koolhaas (1978) and others. These studies are 'based on examination of unplanned and unconscious processes of aspects of urban development that where repressed, went unnoticed, or marginalised whose potential for future planning practices was opened up. […] the investigation of the real-life city also served as a critique of the prevailing orthodoxies of urban planning and architects.' (Oswalt et al., 2013: 8)

The concept of urban informality has a rich background in development studies, with many scholars even questioning the term itself and its various meanings (see for example Herle & Fokdal, 2011). In the context of 'old industrial nations' (Urban Catalyst: 9) the concept of informality can be understood as having to do 'less with slums and informal economies' but defined as a 'process of informalisation' meaning a tendency towards deregulation of planning and structural shifts in governance, where informal civic-society based actors (citizen groups, co-operatives) have more of a say in physical development' (Matthiesen et al., 2014: 86, author's translation). It could be argued what this shift also changes the physical aspects of urban development. Porter (2011) notes that 'actually existing informality might include self-build housing; the 'illegality' of traveller settlements in European cities; illegal housing in contexts of rapid urbanisation; street vendors who operate without the structure and protection of legal systems; unregulated labour markets; squatters rights'.

Municipalities, especially those in weak financial situation, have understood the importance of these projects and have supported a number of publications. For example Senate Department for Urban Development and the Environment in Berlin has part-funded such publications exploring the subjects as 'Urban Pioneers' (Overmeyer, 2007) which explored informal appropriation of space in Berlin in and 'Self-Made City' (Ring et al., 2013) which looked at citizen-made housing. Most recently a special issue of 'Trends in Urban Development Series' by Federal office for Building and Regional Planning' (BBSR in Germany) in 2014, has shown that informality has also become an essential part of a mainstream urban planning discourse in Germany. The situation is similar in other EU countries.

In many cases this academic discourse and research went hand in hand with financial support for so called informal activities and actors. EU and National governments funded a number of physical pilot project which explore further the findings of the discourses above, for example, 'Gangsviertel' (Derwanz and Vollmer, 2015), as well a number of state-funded meanwhile use agencies like ZZZ in Bremen (ZZZ Bremen, 2016) and Zwischennutzung Agentur Wuppertal (BBSR, 2011).

Within these projects the architect plays the role of a facilitator/mediator, where he or she spend far less time designing and far more working alongside various community actors to develop not just physical, but technical, legal, and financial aspects of the project (Laberenne and Minnery, 2015) as well as fund-raising for the project and liaising with municipality and other stakeholders.

In these kinds of projects it has become more problematic to rely on governmental funding alone, as support programmes and funding levels vary across the countries. In order to fund citizen-led development new models and streams of funding have become available.

Funding streams

By looking at the variety of informal or bottom up urban projects across Europe three broad categories of funding support were identified – fundings from State, Market and Civil Society. In reality most projects are funded through the combination of all of these categories, with some of the funding streams like Charitable Foundations being attributed to more than one category. Examples of each type are presented below.

State funding

Although there is not many funds which specifically fund informal urban development, there are many cases of bottom-up projects receiving a number of small funding grants for parts of their activities. e.g educational activities which provide organisation with cash flow. For example, the municipality of Hamburg pays for a number “most responsible and time-consuming” (Derwanz & Vollmer, 2015: 233) positions in Geangeviertel, a “non-commercial urban space” (Derwanz & Vollmer, 2015: 241) comprising of offices, event locations & workshops, as well as supports a number of galleries there. This is made in return for “activists’ high amount of voluntary work in the process” (Derwanz & Vollmer, 2015: 241).

1. Geangeviertel, Hamburg

Besides general funding, government can support informal actors in other ways, for example, by allowing the use of their assets at reduced rate, e.g empty sites and vacant buildings given for temporary use for free. Financial reliefs, incl. tax reduction. For example, in Prinzessinnengarten project in Berlin the city municipality has given a site on a short-term lease to the local community at the minimal rent rate to be developed into an urban garden.

To receive this support actors have to have a certain level of formalisation depending on the size and conditions of the project. In case of Prinzessinnengarten for example, the group of activists have formed a non-for profit company. This also allowed to legalise business activities of the group, like food-sales and events.

Initial lease conditions for the Prinzessinnengarten only allowed a temporary lease for one-year at a time, thus the garden has been growing in mobile planting containers, to be able to move to a different site if required. Here the legal contract in many ways effected the physical appearance of the development. (Nomadisch Grün, 2016)

2. Prinzessinnengarten, Berlin

Market funding

One of the most common examples of corporate funding of informal urban projects relates to developers funding kick-starter activities on their sites to raise land value of their land and reduce the runnings costs while it stands empty. In most cases supported programmes on site are temporary, and citizens involved in the process of enhancing the neighbourhood are never envisioned as part of the long-term structure.

One of the examples of this is Spitalfield's Market, London. During the real estate collapse in the 1990's developers allowed and financed temporary use in their property in order to prevent vandalism on empty building, reduce maintenance costs, but most importantly to increase acceptance of the planned office district in at that point very deprived parts of London. They organised a market, sports facilities, event venues, cafe's and bars as well as subsidised not economically viable uses like artist studios and events.

For about five years temporary projects, with their great atmosphere, worked as magnet for the site weekly attracting thousands of visitors. Local community organisations formed a citizen's initiative to prevent further re-development. However when the construction of the offices became economically viable for the developers, the group was not strong enough to win a legal fight. Despite the loss, temporary use allowed to bring into the area more varied development, which now also included community centres and social housing, as developers had to do more to convince local population and city's administration with positive affects of their redevelopment and the eviction of its temporary tenants. (Oswalt et al., 2013: 264 - 271)

This support always has an end goal – which is benefiting the future development and increasing its market value, which in most cases does not include informal actors.

Private Charitable funds and Foundations

Foundations are nonprofit organisations supporting others for charitable purposes - it could be argued that these are non-commercial forms of funding. Although Foundations have a long track records, their more recent activities are of bigger interest, having ever increasing role in urban development. This has been particularly noticeable in Germany, with many highly publicised projects being funding through this way in Berlin in particular.

Stiftung Abendrot foundation, together with local co-operative Holzmarkt eG, has bought a wasteland in Berlin on the Spree in 2012, to help realise a mixed use development that includes an incubator with affordable spaces for creative start-ups, artist village, urban garden, day-care centre and much more. In a highly competitive situation and paying the highest bid for the land, the scheme resisted the development of corporate office space and luxury apartments. (Abendrot, 2016)

Another example shows Edith Maryon foundation saving one of the last remaining 'alternative living and cultural centres' - Schokolden eV, in Mitte area, Berlin. Former chocolate factory occupied by artists since 1990s – offering varied cultural programme including theatre and music events, artists and rehearsal studios. The group has been forced into eviction continuously since the beginning. In 2012 the foundation have purchased the building, and secured long term lease with tenants. So the group is there now - still keeping the ticket prices low, emphasising its social aims in one of the most expensive parts of Berlin. (Edith Maryon, 2016)

3. Schokolden, Berlin


In these examples Foundations are helping to secure position to the newly formed or already established groups without restricting their aims. Without putting strict conditions on the development, or depoliticising the group.

Some foundations are found with charitable aims related to socially-driven urban regeneration aspirations, like Edith Maryon. Others are just looking for more social places to invest their money, like Stiftung Abendrot, which is a pension fund.

Civil society funding

In the context of this discussion we refer to Civic Society as a 'third sector' - meaning not belonging to 'governmental' or 'business sphere'. Thus, under this term we can arguably categorise forms of funding support that presents non-market forms of investment and exchange. These can include: co-operative models of ownership; peer-to-peer lending – lending without intermediary financial institutions; time banking – exchange of services with a 'time-value'; venture funding - seed funding for growth; crowd-funding - raising small amounts from large number of people; community shares and many more. (Tonkiss, 2014)

Social-media plays essential role here in helping to reach out for public support, and innovative design and development practices are already creating online communities of clients.

A 350 meter temporary wooden pedestrian bridge build in Rotterdam through the crowd funding initiative launched by urban/architecture collective ZUS in 2011 and completed in 2013. Organised in response to city official's announcements that a permanent bridge can be only build in 30 years. Crowd-funders were able to fund sections of the bridge, or even just a plank in exchange for the name. The campaign raised 100,000 euros out of 140,000 projects budget. This modest example of crowd funding shows citizens becoming directly involved in urban transformation process on a small scale, using web and digital applications, in the context of less strict planning permits for temporary buildings. (Ferguson, 2014)

Another example, crowd-funding of a whole new building – Glyncoch Community Centre in Wales, raising 792,433 pounds in 2012 through 'Spacehive' crowd funding platform – especially dedicated to funding environment and building projects. With municipal budget's being cut the activists launching the campaign were hoping to reverse a cycle of deprivation in the neighbourhood. (Michael and Goodinson, 2014)
4. Glyncoch Community Centre, Glyncoch

Or community garden '123rd Street Garden' in Harlem, New York, was destroyed by a building collapse in 2012. Community has banded together to raise funds to rebuild it, using the crowdfunding site IOBY- especially dedicated to neighbourhood improvement projects, claiming the that neighbours know better what their neighbourhood needs. 20 dollars /year Membership scheme and a volunteers effort helps to run the space now. (IOBY, 2013)(123rd Street Block Association, 2015)

It can be argued these form of support lead to less bureaucratic or formalised outcomes, without much restriction to the proposals of the campaigners, really relying on big numbers of public approval. (Ferguson, 2014)

Discussion

All funding streams have their own objectives and reasons why they give out money. In order to receive this support, a certain level of formalisation is required from informal actors like for example having a formal company structure and, strict governance & financial arrangements. This sometimes leads to changes in the aims of the group, greater pursuit of financial return and perhaps letting go of more social, but less profitable uses (UC: 324). However, different streams force different levels of formalisation.

Any contribution in the business sector has to be a business investment, thus involvement of business sponsorship in many cases 'comes with the price' for the group, as in 'Spitalfield's Market' example. Corporate sponsorship is often dictated through personal preference when choosing a certain project to other, requiring negotiation skills from the group and extensive network of interest in the project.

As in the business funding, government can also use the civic projects as a tool to increase certain area-land values without considering the long-term involvement of the group in process. In Prinzessinnengarten project tenants were given the site on a yearly renewable lease agreement. In 2012, however they have managed to avoid the eviction when the land was about to be sold – an open letter to the Senate and support campaign of 30,000 people has allowed to renew the lease to another 5 years. A small victory considering the popularity of the site and campaign effort.

Foundations and crowd-funding seem to have less stringent demands and conditions from the formal actors, which can be argued makes the outcome of the physical projects more varied and exciting.

Conclusion

As informal urban practices have become part of the mainstream urban discourse, informal urban actors are having a greater say in urban development in the context of deregulation of planning and structural shifts towards governance.

Today informal actors don't have to rely solely on the government to obtain financial support for their projects – with the funding available from state, market and civil society sources. As the number of examples have shown, these sources have different aims and objectives and demand various levels of formalisation from the actors.

While more traditional sources like government funding require more stringent levels of formalisation and the majority of market funding being given with aims which don't include those of the actual actors, new forms of funding from foundations and decentralised civil society, like crowd funding, offer informal urban actors ways to develop their social projects with far less constraints.

Bibliography

Abendrot, Stiftung (2016), Abendrot – Die Nachhaltige Pensionskasse. available at http://www.abendrot.ch/deutsch/aktuell/neue-geldanlagen.php [10 January 2016].
BBSR (2011), Wuppertal „Zwischennutzungsagentur“. available at http://www.werkstatt-stadt.de/de/projekte/228/ [10 January 2016].
Derwanz, Heike and Vollmer, Hans (2015), Grassroots Initiatives as Pioneers of Low-Budget Practices: An Activists’ Roundtabl. Ephemera, 15(1): 229–247.
Edith Maryon, Stiftung (2016), Schokoladen, Berlin (D). available at http://www.maryon.ch/foundation/en/schokoladen/#.VpJtu8ArK2w [10 January 2016].
Ferguson, Francesca (Ed.) (2014), Make_Shift City: Renegotiating the Urban Commons. Jovis.
IOBY (2013), The New 123rd Street Community Garden. available at https://www.ioby.org/project/new-123rd-street-community-garden [10 January 2016].
Laberenne, Rebecca and Minnery, Rachel (2015), How Today’s Architects Contribute to Resilient Cities. GreenBiz. available at http://www.greenbiz.com/article/how-todays-architects-contribute-resilient-cities [10 January 2016].
Matthiesen, Ulf, Misselwitz, Philipp and Kaltenbrunner, Robert (2014), Zur Bedeutung Des Informellen in Der Stadtentwicklung. Informationen zur Raumentwicklung, 2.
Michael, Chris and Goodinson, Elena (2014), We Built This City: The Smartest Urban Crowdfunding Projects. The Guardian. available at http://www.theguardian.com/cities/gallery/2014/apr/28/crowdfunding-we-built-this-city-the-smartest-urban-projects-in-pictures [10 January 2016].
Muessigmann, Lena (2014), Basler Wertekanon an Der Spree. die Tageszeitung. available at http://www.taz.de/1/archiv/digitaz/artikel/?ressort=bt&dig=2014%2F02%2F08%2Fa0208&cHash=c22af19eefd2e4a87254eaa8118a1a33 [10 January 2016].
Nomadisch Grün (2016), About Prinzessinnengarten. available at http://prinzessinnengarten.net/about/ [10 January 2016].
Oswalt, Philipp, Overmeyer, Klaus and Misselwitz, Philipp (2013), Urban Catalyst: The Power of Temporary Use. Berlin: DOM Publishers.
Overmeyer, Klaus (Ed.) (2007), Urban Pioneers: Temporary Use and Urban Development in Berlin. Berlin: Jovis.
Ring, Kristien, PROJECTS, AA and Berlin, Senatsverw f Stadtentw /Umwelt (2013), Selfmade City Berlin: Stadtgestaltung Und Wohnprojekte in Eigeninitiative. Berlin: Jovis Berlin.
Tagesspiel (2007), Rotaprint Bleibt Künstlerland. available at http://www.tagesspiegel.de/berlin/ehemaliges-firmengelaende-rotaprint-bleibt-kuenstlerland/1034924.html [5 January 2016].
Tonkiss, Fran (2014), From Austerity to Audacity: Make – Shift Urbanism and the Post-Crisis City, , in: Make_Shift City. Jovis.
ZZZ Bremen (2016), ZwischenZeitZentrale Bremen. available at http://www.zzz-bremen.de/blog/ [10 January 2016].

Image reference

1.Sanierungsgebiet Neustadt SU2, Gängeviertel/Valentinskamp [Photograph] available at
http://www.steg-hamburg.de/stadterneuerung-stadtentwicklung/gaengeviertel-neustadt-SU2.html [10 January 2016].
2. Doch noch Zukunft für den Schokoladen? [Photograph] available at http://static.bz-berlin.de/data/uploads/multimedia/archive/00344/Schokoladen_344243a-1024x576.jpg [10 January 2016].
3. About Prinzessinnengarten [Photograph] avaialable at thtp://prinzessinnengarten.net/about/ [10 January 2016].
4. Glyncoch Community Centre [Photograph]
available at https://spacehive.com/glyncochcc [10 January 2016].